Pie Day

I made a list of 33 things I want to do before I turn 33 in June 2014.  See the full list here.

26. Make a pie. I really need to conquer my fear of baking.


“When [Almanzo] began to eat pie, he wished he had eaten nothing else. He ate a piece of pumpkin pie and a piece of custard pie, and he ate almost a piece of vinegar pie. He tried a piece of mince pie, but could not finish it. He just couldn’t do it. There were berry pies and cream pies and vinegar pies and raisin pies, but he could not eat any more.” — Farmer Boy, Laura Ingalls Wilder

My dear mother came to town to help with bread baking, but when it came time to tackle making a pie, I turned to my mother-in-law.  I grew up enjoying Mom’s bread, cinnamon rolls, cookies, crisps and cobblers, but she wasn’t a pie mom.IMG_3513

Corinne, however, was a State Champion pie baker (Entrant No. 10, actually).  So on Mother’s Day, she pulled out her old recipe card and we baked a pie.  Two pies, actually.  Over achievers.


Isn’t that cookie jar just the cutest?  I’m totally putting a sticky note with my name on it in hopes of inheriting it someday.  And you guys.  LARD.  Corinne said she found it with the cottage cheese, not with the butter, like we both had sort of expected.


Anyway.  We cut in the butter and lard until we had little peas, being careful not to overwork the dough.

Corinne floured up the pastry cloth on its little frame and slipped the sleeve on the rolling pin.  I remembered my sticky dough near-mess from baking bread and sighed in relief.  I rolled out the dough for a 9-inch pie pan.

Then I tried (not so successfully) to get the pie crust into the pie pan without tearing it or poking holes through the tender dough.  Corinne showed me how to patch the holes  – no one will see the inside, she reminded me.  IMG_3530

Then time for the cherries.  I am not sure if I’ve ever had tart cherries from a can before  – these were in water not syrup – but they are SO good.  I had to restrain myself from eating too many before they made it in the pie.  We mixed the sugar and juice and cornstarch and heated until thickened, the stirred in the glossy butter and plump cherries.  Mmmm.  So good.IMG_3531

I used a nifty tool to cut the pretty lattice strips.
IMG_3533But don’t look too closely – I was not good at the weaving part, and the lattice strips kept breaking so I gave up and faked it a bunch.IMG_3534

Then we made an apple pie, because two pies is better than one pie, clearly.  I actually did a pretty good job moving the top crust on this one.   IMG_3544

We put them in the oven, and when there was about 30 minutes left, the tornado siren went off.  Not even joking.  A tornado warning vs. my beautiful pies!  What were we going to do?

We all went down to the basement and watched the news as the storm moved closer.  And closer.  Straight line winds and rain-wrapped tornados in the area prompted us to move into an interior bedroom, so I dashed upstairs, and with 10 minutes left on the oven timer, I turned off the oven (but left the pies in), ran back downstairs, drank more wine, and hoped for the best.  20 minutes later, the storm had passed and I went up to check on my pies.

Overall, I think they would have been better baked at the proper temperature for the full time, but considering their low-temp long hangout, they sure were good.  And pretty.  IMG_3535

I’m thankful for the time that Corinne spent with me, and I feel good enough about making pie crust that I’ll try it again.  Above:  Totally the best part about pie making, amiright?  Below:  The woman who gave life to the man I love.  She has a pretty special place in my heart.  Screen Shot 2014-05-16 at 7.32.52 PM

6 thoughts on “Pie Day

  1. Jennifer Flaa (@JeniEats)

    Those pies look beautiful and now I want to make a cherry pie. It’s so wonderful your mother in law could share her tips. I was too intimidated to ever try making pie dough until my culinary teacher walked me through it. Sometimes it’s nice just to have someone make it with you the first time.

  2. Kelly in Oregon

    It always makes me laugh how ever baker, or any artist really, always points out the flaws. I always do this myself! When you spend time on it, that’s all you see. But no one else sees them, truly. I saw your lattice and I thought oh how CUTE, I should do my next pie crust that way… both with the fun cut and I liked how they were skinny and close together, I always do thicker strips further apart. And then I read that you faked it, and then I looked back and it and saw what you see. 🙂

    1. awastell Post author

      I had such high hopes for the lattice weaving, and then…nope. But it looked pretty after baking and it tasted delicious!

  3. Joann

    BEAUTIFUL! I have pie envy! I haven’t been able to make a great pie crust or pie filling EVER and my mama made the most incredible pies!

  4. Pingback: 33 before 33 | Team Wastell

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s